Rubric 3: Analytic Grading-How to boost your level of skill
| bad | requirements enhancement | Good | Excellent | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thesis | No argument that is overarching be discerned. | Is confusing, contradictory or underdeveloped. Will not fit well with all the scope associated with the project. Importance is confusing. | Exists and it is comprehensible, if underdeveloped in places. Could be extremely broad or unoriginal. Importance is talked about. | Is original, innovative, insightful and provocative. Is suitable to your project’s scale. Importance is actually explained. |
| proof | Either no proof is supplied, or there are several mistakes that are factual omissions or oversimplifications. Author greatly overstates importance of proof. | Hinges on few sources. Not sufficient evidence is supplied to aid writer’s argument, or proof is incomplete, oversimplified or incorrect. Limits of proof aren’t well recognized. | Several different forms of sources is employed to aid arguments. Provides necessary proof to persuade audience on most facets of the primary argument. Need for proof often assumed. | A broad array of sources is found in imaginative approaches to help arguments. Smoothly integrates wider knowledge to spell out evidence. Pupil shows the restrictions of various kinds of proof. |
| Organization | Essay doesn’t have clear pattern that is organizational. | Exists during the phrase level. Paragraphs shortage clear direction, additionally the logic associated with the paper in general is obscure. Argument will not build. Introduction and summary are boring, banal or repeated. | Exists during the paragraph degree. The argument might perhaps not build due to the fact paper techniques. Does not eclipse the senior high school essay that is five-paragraph. Conclusion and introduction are heavy-handed. | Aids the argument, which develops through the paper. Paragraphs and subsections regarding the paper are connected. Paper proceeds having a logic. Introduction attracts your reader in; conclusion doesn’t merely summarize. |
| Research | Does Not analyze. Problems of counter-evidence or alternative interpretations aren’t addressed. | Efforts at analysis are mainly perhaps not fruitful. Author acknowledges a few of the most apparent counter-evidence and alternate explanations. There was minimal effort designed to answer them. | Will not include much insight that is new the topic. Author completely acknowledges counter-evidence or alternative interpretations but will not efficiently neutralize them. | Is persuasively argued. Identifies and describes counter-arguments or alternate theories. Demonstrates a knowledge associated with the restrictions of this proof. Ties into broad themes and some ideas |
| Knowledge | Demonstrates small familiarity with the subject material. | Demonstrates some knowledge of the subject material but has difficulty integrating it in to the paper. | Demonstrates knowledge that is basic of industry plus the key concerns, activities and themes that form regarding the paper. | Demonstrates understanding of the field and relates paper to wider occasions, themes and arguments. |
| Mechanics and type | Mechanics and style can be a barrier to understanding. Composing is filled with grammatical mistakes. Terms are misused. Rhetoric replaces argumentation, and never perfectly. | Composing is confusing, in component due to errors in spelling, sentence structure, diction and use. Employs hackneyed rhetoric and shopworn metaphors. | Composing is usually clear and comprehensible, even though it may include minor mistakes of sentence structure, spelling, usage or diction. Lacks initial sound and attracts on widely used metaphors. | Composing is obvious and succinct. Good sentence structure, spelling, usage and diction all donate to the paper’s success. Stylistic innovations, rhetoric and employ of metaphors all further conceptual understanding. |
Analytic Grading Rubric (developed by Peter Pihos, University of Pennsylvania)
Browse The Campus
We are going to demonstrate around and familiarizes you with one of the more breathtaking campuses in the nation. Today arrange a tour.
Outstanding Teachers
Our very trained faculty are leaders within their areas. Come study from them.
Direct Admissions
Learn to use on campus for undergraduate classes for the autumn 2019 semester.
Housing Options
Read about housing options that are offered in Brooklyn.
© 2019 All Rights Reserved Brooklyn College 2900 Bedford Avenue, Brooklyn, NY 11210 718.951.5000 ipadress is-10.0.10.1
